Artie vs. Airbyte Cloud
Airbyte Cloud reads your database every 5 to 60 minutes at best, so your warehouse is always behind. Artie is managed CDC for production databases. The destination matches production in real time, the source never slows down, and our engineers get paged, not yours.
When an Airbyte Cloud sync breaks, your team fixes it.
With Artie, our engineers get paged, not yours.
| Factor | Airbyte Cloud | |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Scheduled ELT across 700+ connectors for APIs, databases, and files | Managed CDC for production databases |
| When WAL is lost | The sync restarts from scratch; an invalidated slot is yours to drop, recreate, and fully re-sync | On Growth and Enterprise, Artie's engineers run the reset and backfill; you restore source prerequisites and authorize it |
| Who is on call | Airbyte runs the platform; failed syncs, slot problems, and re-syncs are your team's. Tickets answered 7am to 7pm Eastern on Standard and Plus, 24/5 on Pro and Enterprise Flex | On Growth and Enterprise, Artie's engineers are paged for infrastructure failures; dedicated Slack or Teams channel; 24/7 and an SLA on Enterprise |
| Postgres replication slot | Holds WAL on your database until the next sync reads it; Airbyte's docs say to sync often so it doesn't fill the disk | Acknowledged after every flush, so the slot stays small instead of growing between syncs |
| Freshness | Scheduled syncs: at most every 60 minutes on Standard, 15 on Plus, and 5 on Pro and Enterprise Flex; one sync per connection at a time | Continuous: every change lands within a minute of commit, on every plan |
| Data in the destination | As of the last sync: the latest row per primary key (Append + Deduped) or every change appended (Incremental Append); deletes hard or soft | Every insert, update, and delete, one row per record; deletes hard, soft, or skipped per table; full change history on request |
| Backfill behavior | Initial loads and refreshes re-read the whole stream; scheduled syncs wait for a refresh to finish while other streams keep syncing | Online, alongside CDC; bounded reads that never block a write, from a read replica where your setup supports it |
| Backfill cost | On Standard and Plus, initial loads, refreshes, and re-syncs spend credits like any other sync, except automatic backfills for new or renamed columns | Free on every plan; backfills never count toward billable rows |
| Schema evolution | Checked before each sync; column changes propagate by setting; incompatible type changes error on new rows; removing a primary key or cursor pauses the connection | New columns added automatically; column drops opt-in, after a 4-hour safety check; renames and type changes flagged, not applied |
| Pricing model | Standard from $20/mo and Plus from $189/mo in credits (databases: 4 credits per GB); Pro and Enterprise Flex priced by Data Worker capacity | Free: $0/mo, up to 1M rows Growth: from $500/mo, based on monthly usage Enterprise: custom pricing |
| Observability | Sync history and logs; email or webhook notifications for failed syncs, successful syncs, and schema changes; OpenTelemetry metrics and monitoring integrations depending on plan | Per-table lag, throughput, and slot size to Datadog or any Prometheus remote-write endpoint; custom monitors and webhooks |
| Deployment options | Airbyte-managed cloud (US on GCP, EU on AWS); Enterprise Flex runs data planes in your infrastructure | Cloud on every plan; BYOC on Enterprise |
| Enterprise compliance | SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, GDPR | SOC 2 Type II; HIPAA with a BAA on Growth and Enterprise |
| Source coverage | 700+ connectors; Airbyte maintains its own, and community-built Marketplace connectors carry no SLA | 14 sources, plus an Events API for custom application events; 17 destinations |
| Architecture | Each sync is a job that reads, loads, and stops; Postgres CDC runs on embedded Debezium | A reader on the transaction log, a Kafka buffer, and a writer that commits its offset only after the destination write succeeds |
| Best fit | Broad ELT where hourly or 15-minute freshness is enough, especially API and SaaS sources | Production databases where the destination has to match the source in real time |
Where Artie wins
Real time instead of scheduled syncs
Airbyte Cloud reads your database at most hourly on Standard, every 15 minutes on Plus, and every 5 on Pro, so your warehouse is as old as the last sync. Artie reads the transaction log continuously: every insert, update, and delete lands within a minute of commit, one row per record, with the full change history when you want it. An hour-old warehouse is fine for a daily dashboard, and too slow for fraud checks, pricing, or an agent acting on what it reads.
No WAL piling up between syncs
Between Airbyte syncs, the replication slot holds WAL on your database until the next sync reads it. Artie acknowledges the log after every flush, so the slot stays small instead of growing between syncs. Backfills are bounded reads that never block a write, and they can run from a read replica.
Our engineers get paged, not yours
When Postgres removes WAL that Airbyte still needs, the sync restarts from scratch, and an invalidated slot is yours to drop, recreate, and re-sync. On Growth and Enterprise, Artie's engineers are paged for infrastructure failures and run the recovery. You still see every failure, backfill, and schema event.
Free backfills instead of per-GB credits
Airbyte Cloud meters database syncs by data volume on Standard and Plus, so initial loads, most refreshes, and wide JSON columns all spend credits. Artie bills by row: one update is one row however many columns changed, and backfills never count. Free covers 1M billable rows a month; Growth is usage-based from $500/month.
Migrate from Airbyte Cloud without disrupting your warehouse
What stays the same
- Your warehouse: Snowflake, BigQuery, Redshift, or Databricks; Enterprise adds Iceberg
- Your destination table names: set them to match the ones you use today
- Your dbt models, dashboards, and BI tools: repoint them to Artie tables one model at a time
- Your Airbyte connections for API and SaaS sources: keep them running. Artie replaces the database connections.
The cutover playbook
- List the Airbyte connections that read from Postgres, MySQL, or MongoDB (SQL Server and Oracle on Enterprise). Leave API and SaaS connections where they are.
- Create an Artie pipeline with its own replication slot and run it in parallel with Airbyte. Artie writes to a separate set of warehouse tables, and the backfill isn't billed.
- Compare row counts, freshness, deletes, and schema handling side by side.
- Cut downstream views or dbt models over to read from Artie tables.
- Turn off the Airbyte database connections you replaced, then drop their replication slots so they stop holding WAL.